Technical topics
Constant
Directivity
WaveGuide
CDWG is the the 17mm wide full range planar
constant-directivity speaker/waveguide.
Patenting of this technology is in the process.
From the outside CDWG looks exactly the same as
regular grilles.
The key to the invention lies in a peculiarity of planar panels: most of the output comes from the center of the transducer, or within about 12mm either side of the center vertical axis. This area is responsible for about 75% of the speaker's radiation over its operating range.
It should therefore be possible to reduce the width of the panel by suitable means to a value which would enhance its directivity while reducing its sensitivity only slightly, 1 to 2 dB of SPL. This must be done without reflecting a lot of energy back into the diaphragm causing frequency response peaks/notches and coloring the sound unacceptably. In other words, one might suspend a disco ball in front of a speaker and improve its directivity, and in so doing destroy whatever good sound qualities the system already possesses.
After much experimentation devised was a slotted waveguide the width of which was the same as the highest frequency for which Constant Directivity was desired. Selected frequency is 20 kHz and a width of about 17mm. The underside of the waveguide, which contacts the panel stators directly, features considerable absorption and some diversion.
The question arises whether enhanced directivity is that important or merely an intellectual exercise. There was no way of knowing without building a CD speaker. The results of imposing the waveguide over an RM 30 or RM 40, as first test subjects, were spectacular. While the tonal character of the speaker was recognizable, there was much more palpability to the image, more of a "they are here" sense, more naturalness--all to a enormous degree. Incorporating the tweeter with its post-20 kHz bandwidth into the waveguide transformed the speaker system into a true full-range CD radiator. You can sit anywhere in front (or directly inbetween) the speakers and enjoy the effect.
Since on axis and off axis response are the same with CDWG, it is much easier to linearize the speaker in a given room, by placement, toe-in, and level control adjustments, or electronically. The Constant Directivity Wave Guide also eliminates lobing inherent to first-order filters in crossover regions, improving fidelity and linearity not possible by other means.
The price you pay is a 1.5dB reduction in midrange sensitivity, which can be compensated for with the level controls which are normally set about 4dB below max output, AND, most importantly, a 6dB/oct rolloff in the trebles above 10kHz, which can be compensated for by various means.
Because a CD configuration spreads the same amount of treble energy over a much wider angle, there is a gentle high-freqency rollof which requires compensation for measurably flat amplitude response. A 6dB/oct boost centered in the 8-10kHz range is necessary. This is easily accomplished by means of:
1. increasing the tweeter level via a potentiometer such as that already in circuit with VMPS tweeters;
2. a standard Baxandall-type treble tone control like on preamps of old and some pre's and integrated amps of today;
3. an equalizer with a 10kHz hinge point;
4. a passive EQ which impresses an inverse rollin to the mids;
5. a dedicated supertweeter operating at a higher level than the main tweeter, crossed over at 6 dB/oct at a higher frequency than the main tweeter;
...and several other remedies such as the new digital speaker correction or room correction outboards (SOCS, DEQX, TACT and their kind).
Many listeners will find the CD treble balance just fine as it is. CD trebles just sound smoother, more realistic and better defined, particularly in relatively undamped listening environments like almost all homes.
Goal was that all VMPS CD speakers work well with and without CD EQ, even if that only means turning up the tweeter level controls a little. The best way to bring up the trebles subjectively is to tighten the bass. We have engineered new low Q passive radiators and lowbass woofers for that purpose. Owners purchasing CD wave guides for their existing speakers will also get the new PR's.
We find the sound of the "revoiced" CD speakers done so far to be punchier and clearer, with no sacrifice of extension. A felicitous byproduct of CD technology, this change should please everyone who tries it.
Cabinets
VMPS cabinets are normally made from MDF
(medium density), except RM/X which uses even
heavier HDF (high-density) and ST III
which bass column has synthetic granite
front plate.
RM/X cabinet is a piece of art in
cabinet making, both technically and
cosmetically. Extremely complicated CNC carved
shape of 14cm thick HDF frontplate ensures
completly stable board for bass driver and an
"invisible" surrounding for array of
six Neo panels. FST tweeter is housed in
completely separate chamber which is angle
adjustable. Cabinet is finished in 7 layers of
automotive lacquer.
New MLS cabinets, available for 626R,
RM30, RM40 and LRC, are made from HDF, and are
heavier and more extensively braced than
standard cabinet. Finishes are beautiful, in
choice of light and dark genuine wood veneers
and high-gloss piano black. All MLS cabinets are
delivered in custom-built wood crates.
Standard oak cabinets of RM2 have massive genuine
oak sides and edges.
Midrange chambers are damped with natural
lamb wool which is the top-quality choice
for damping rear midrange radiation. There is no doubt in my mind the lambswool is a step forward in clarity and naturalness.
Lamb wool is also not a good choice for bass
section, being not reactive enough for good low
frequency absorption. For bass we use
fiberglass.
Soundcoat is ceramic compound which is
in liquid state when applying and hardens when
dry after a couple of days. It is very effective
in damping unwanted cabinet resonance, around
10dB in audio range above 200Hz. Newest option
for even beter results are BlackHole 5
self-adhesive plates.
Crossover
VMPS uses first order networks and in-phase
drivers because that emulates live music
best. Material used as standard is first rate (Erse "Super Q",
Solen, Bennic, Axon, Vishay), and absolute best
capacitors from Auricaps and TRT
are offered as option at additional cost. We
build passive crossovers to very tight
tolerances. For us that means four
decimal places, or 1/2000th of 1%. Each
crossover is trimmed to exact value, no
tolerances. This means, for example, 1.600uF,
not 1.6uF. You only get repeatability with high
levels of precision.We laugh at the tolerances
(5%, 1%) even the best competitors use. All
connections are soldered point to point,
no printed board is used. This solution does not
look very good, but sounds much better.
Our "Super Q" Erse coils are superior to any aircore, since their DCR is about
35% of an equivalent gauge aircore of the same value. It has nothing to do with cost, the Erse's aren't cheap either. DCR is the most important characteristic of a series inductor as long as it does not saturate or suffer from hysteresis. The very large laminar core of the Erse's eliminates both problems and sound just wonderful, which is why
we use them.
Crossover includes two L-pads for level
adjustment of midrange panels and tweeter.
We use them instead of fixed resistors because
L-pads allow a 1/20th of 1dB change in level
to be effected by the user. Often such a
change is all that is needed to tame hot trebles
or a forward midrange. A fixed value does not
allow the user to adapt the music to his tastes.
Also, resistors are not made with sufficient
tolerances to give us the precision we feel
necessary for level changes. You can't get this level of precision with a stepped attenuator or a resistor network. In fact even 1% tolerance Vishays (which we use elsewhere in the xover) do not permit this level of precision, which can be very important when you switch equipment or IC's/speaker wire.
Also, fixed parts change value with age and
there's nothing you can do about that. L-pads
change too, but all you have to do is move the
wiper over one winding and you're back in
business. Fixed values are invariably determined
by measurement, i.e. whatever meassures flattest
with your mic and test gear and environment.
However, bass below 200Hz is boundary-dependent;
fixed values do not allow for changes in room or
placement. You're going to be wrong virtually
100% of the time, no matter what you think your
measurements tell you is best. Our L-pads allow great flexibility and microadjustments that nothing else approaches. Rather than a compromise, the Lpad gives the user essential freedom to adjust the system to taste.
The level control adjustments are essential to obtaining optimum performance from any of our systems.
This also comes from general knowledge of basic acoustics and psychoacoustics.
Crossover and midrange/high frequency drivers
are connected with custom silver/teflon wire.
Standard wire for bass connection is Monster
copper wire. Option for this purpose is Bolder
silver wire.
Binding posts we use are selected
because they have been proven best for a number
of years and are best suited for accepting
spades. They are solid brass/gold plated, with
6mm shafts, solid metal nut that can be tightened with a nut driver. There is no hole through the center of the shaft (for the
bare wire) which weakens the shaft and causes
breakage.
FST
"Free
swinging tweeter" is the latest true-ribbon
tweeter used throughout VMPS line. It is one of
the best tweeters available today. It's
advantages over previous spiral ribbon tweeters
were easily audible and cost is not overly
prohibitive. We use custom version (8 Ohm,
custom transformer and diaphragm) of similarly
looking Aurum Cantus tweeter. The FST tweeter has 30
degrees of vertical dispersion, less than 25 mm
dome tweeter, but does not become directional at 11 kHz like a
25 mm dome. Horizontal dispersion is broad and even up to 25 kHz.
Foam pads surround the opening of the
diaphragm, slot-loading the tweeters for better horizontal disperson.
Foam pads won't be necessary when all VMPS
speakers are converted to CDWG.
Neo panel
The star of the VMPS ribbon speakers are
their midrange panels, a rebuilt Level 9
products. "Neo" comes from Neodymium,
element that is a part of magnet material
(NeFeB). Level 9 built about 300,000 of these panels most of which ended up in computers, where they worked OK. In high fidelity and automotive applications they failed at a high rate due to a mechanical design flaw, which requires us to rebuild each one. With our
rebuilt they have been durable and good sounding. They are the only such panels which extend down to
200 Hz and below, a critical range.
Neo panels are available only at VMPS
loudspeakers. Similar competing products are not
nearly up to it, not having enough upper bas
response, or having large nonlinearities etc.
Bass drivers
We make our own bass drivers for decades and
do not use anything short of best possible for
the purpose. That means custom made Woven
Carbon Fibre cones in various sizes, natural
rubber surrounds, 300W voicecoils, 2.3kg
magnets. Driving our woofers with 20Hz signal to
loudness of 115 dB we can see (not just theorize) cone travels of at least plus/minus 15 mm.
Also, we are unique in suspending the spider on
bass drivers. Check the articles Cone Talk - Materials
and Why
suspend a spider? to learn more
on bass drivers construction.
All drivers has phase plugs instead of
usual dustcaps. Appropriately designed phase
plugs are superior to any kind of dustcap,
inverted or not. We haven't used dustcaps on our
drivers for more than 10 years. The phase plugs
are precisely the length and bluntness needed to
move the woofer acoustic center forward to match
the planar sections.
In place of noisy ports at large speakers there is a tunable
passive radiator (PR). It is plenty fast for music and has the heft, extension and output levels for HT.
Sealed designs either cut off an octave or two higher than the
PR design, or are very inefficient. Not what you want.
A PR is basically a tunable vent and allows you to match system Q to the series R of your speaker wire and output impedance of your amp. A necessary feature for good bass. While we tune the PR at the factory for what sounds right on our gear, yours and your room are certainly different. Just follow the setup instructions.
So, all our drivers are custom and almost all are made in
US, by VMPS or custom for VMPS. There is no clones
of our speakers out there.
VMPS Bass system
The Passive Radiator (PR) located in the
bottom of the cabinet already has a certain
amount of mass attached to the center, by the
factory. By adding or subtracting mass from the
PR, it is possible to make system tonal balance
warmer (higher Q) or tighter (lower Q). This is
accomplished by changing an inert mass such as
Mortite rope putty, the substance attached to
the PR. You can buy additional putty at most
hardware stores but your speaker is delivered
over-damped (a bit too much putty), so that in
almost all cases, you will tune the speakers by
removing mass from the PR. Mass is accessible by
inserting your hand into the slot formed by the
base and the bottom of the cabinet. Removing a
very small amount, no more than 1gram of putty,
will be sufficient to make the adjustment.
Moving mass of PR is very low. Since a PR is driven equally over its entire surface by the active woofer's backwave, the diaphragm will move pistonically even if it is not rigid.
The PR cones are treated paper. Paper is fine as
long as you don't have to listen to their high
frequency noise and distortion products. Facing
the PR down and slot-loading it out the front
filters such products out nicely.
We invented the slot-loaded PR and decided not to patent it, since
we would spend our life in court defending against
copies. We knew we were on the right track when
we saw a Klipsch monitor at the AES in 1984 with a slot-loaded PR.
Bottom of the Larger
subwoofer that forms a slot-loading with the
floor, showing 38cm PR with added mass at the
center of the PR
Minimum phase
Minimum phase response means that the envelope of frequencies arrives at the ear at the same time and in phase.
To do this we use first-octave crossovers (phase linear) and wire all drivers electrically in phase. Phase plugs in the woofers move their acoustic center forward to the blunt tip of the phase plug, and into the same plane as the mid and treble ribbons. Since these are planar they do not need to be moved back relative to the woofer's acoustic center.
There are "time aligned" speakers that wire midranges electrically of inverted polarity relative to the woofer and tweeter, which results in measurable better amplitude response. Of course it also destroys the integrity of the music signal outside the crossover region. Phase changes 180 degrees as the signal exits crossover and into the passband, a highly deleterious and audible effect.
If you have more technical questions,
please check FAQ or send us an
e-mail.
|